Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next—organized in one searchable journal.

648 reviews

All Categories

Tabacos TB Baez Don Pepin review photo
Cigars

Tabacos TB Baez Don Pepin

8/10

This cigar was very interesting. It had a good draw it smokes slowly and had very sweet flavors at the beginning. As I got further down the cigar some real strong bitter flavors started to…

Reviewed May 15, 2016Read full review
Gurkha cellah reserv review photo
Cigars

Gurkha Cellah Reserv

7/10

Very good flavor, lots of different complex tastes. Changes as the cigar goes by. The major complaint is the draw is too fast . Even though it's a short cigar it last a long time.

Reviewed May 12, 2016Read full review
Americana review photo
Root Beer

Americana

7/10

This root beer was pretty good and had a very strong peppermint taste a little bit too strong for me.

Reviewed Apr 28, 2016Read full review
Afr-75 review photo
Cigars

Afr-75

4/10

This cigar was too bitter and acidic. Especially for the price. I wouldn't get this one again.

Reviewed Mar 29, 2016Read full review
Pdr 1878 capa masura review photo
Cigars

Pdr 1878 Capa Masura

8/10

This cigar was bittersweet, literally. Every I seem to have different flavors it was a taste that most closely resembles the way cigars smell. Very good draw.

Reviewed Mar 24, 2016Read full review
Warlock review photo
Cigars

Warlock

8/10

This is a very good robust bold flavored cigar. It has a very slow burn and it was very enjoyable.

Reviewed Mar 11, 2016Read full review
Alec Bradley coyol review photo
Cigars

Alec Bradley Coyol

7/10

The cigar is a standard cigar. It's what you imagine a regular cigarette tastes like it has a good draw a good flavor but there is nothing unusual or different about it.

Reviewed Feb 28, 2016Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional