Reviews from the things I actually try

Bunnahabhain 12 Year Old Islay Single Malt Scotch Whisky

Good taste. Really amps up after you take a sip, lots of caramel coming through. Honey too. Very good.

Benriiach Three Cast Matured 10 Year

pretty good. Caramel flavors. 8/10

Tamdhu

sweet, a bit fruity. 7/10

Lugavilin In The Distillers Edition

7.8/10

I Am Little Bay

sweet and pleasant. 7.8/10

Highland Park 21

complex a little bit of caramel to the flavor, 8.5 out of 10

Bruiichladdich 18 Year

powerful. Lots of wood. A little caramel. 8/10

Glenfiddich 18

smooth but not much flavor. 6.1

Isle Of Jura 10

mild flavors but good. Reminds me of the sea. 7.8

Caol Ila 12 Year

Petey, Smokey, lots of different flavors hitting at the same time. Sweet leather 8.1

Ledaig 18

interesting flavors, almost like rubber, not in a bar way. 7.2

Compass Peat Monster Cask

huge flavor, peat like crazy, burns tongue. 8.3

Bruichladdich Dark Arts Canin May Have It

Longgrow Red Malbec Cask 10 Year

lots of wood and heat. Very complex flavor. A hint of smoke. 8.1

Aberfeldy 12 Year

not much to write. Not a lot of flavor. 6/10

Belvenie 14 Caribbean

the lightness of belvenie that I expect. 7.6

Ardbeg Spectacular

8/10. Rich, smokey, delicious.

The Matsui

Very light, smooth complex flavor

Macallaen Rare Cask

5/10

Anerlor

smooth, nothing unique but good, 6.8/10