Cigars
Padilla Reserva San Andres
The draw is pretty terrible. The flavor has a lot of hay and wood This cigar is unsmokable.
Reviewed Oct 3, 2025Read full review
Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.
Reviews from the things I actually try
Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next—organized in one searchable journal.
335 reviews
Cigars
Cigars
Sencillo Edición Limitada Nicaragua 2024 Black
It has subtle notes of grass and hay. Very good draw. Not very complex.
Reviewed Oct 1, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Arturo Fuente: The Untold Story
Sweet, ok draw. Getting hints of coffee. Getting more complexity towards the end here in the last third. It's very good but for the price I still am going to keep it at about a six out of 1…
Reviewed Sep 28, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Rocky Patel Fusion
Pretty good draw. Really on the high end actually. Immediately getting some dark chocolate and nutty tastes from it. Fall leaves. About one-third into it the flavor is pretty mediocre. Not…
Reviewed Sep 27, 2025Read full review
Cigars
EP Carrillo Encore Black
Starting off with a good draw, smooth flavor too. You can tell the fermentation is there. Getting some leather now about one-third in. Very good. Flavor is the same as before but more so.
Reviewed Sep 26, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Esteban Carreras - Covenant
The draw on this cigar is amazing, the flavors are powerful and complex. It has almost a barbecue sauce quality to it, I don't know much about this brand or anything about it but this cigar…
Reviewed Sep 25, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Penn Standard 8-year
Doesn't start off with a lot of flavor but now that I'm about a third in and I'm starting to detect some of the complexity. It's got some wood, some vanilla? It's a bit of lighter flavor th…
Reviewed Sep 23, 2025Read full review
Cigars
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero
Decent draw, not the best but flavor has tons of chocolate.
Reviewed Sep 20, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Warriors On The Fly
I don't really know anything about this cigar who makes it it came in a pack of cigars I got. So far the draw is decent I've only had a few puffs so I don't even know what's going on with t…
Reviewed Sep 19, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Alec Bradley Fine And Rare
Pretty good smoke production a lot of sweetness. Not super complex yet very one-note sweetness but it feels like more is coming. About halfway through now and I'm getting some oak and the s…
Reviewed Sep 17, 2025Read full review
Cigars
La Flor Dominicana Double Ligero
Pretty smooth, the draw is pleasant but on the low side of acceptable. Not a great draw but adequate. It's sweet and it smells like barbecue. Enjoyable flavor. Flavors getting a lot better…
Reviewed Sep 16, 2025Read full review
Cigars
E.P. Carrillo Pledge
Maybe fig? It has a lingering flavor which is unusual at the beginning it had kind of a bread flavor too. I'm having a lot of trouble pinpointing the notes on this one though. It's very enj…
Reviewed Sep 14, 2025Read full review
Cigars
E.P. Carrillo La Historia Silk
I'm getting some leather, you can taste its good aged fermentation. It starts off with a sweetness.
Reviewed Sep 14, 2025Read full review
Cigars
God Of Fire Serie B Maduro
Immediately great taste, great draw, great smoke production. Minimum 8.
Reviewed Sep 12, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Double Chateau Fuente
So far really good draw and flavor. The color of the wrapper really stands out. It's one of the most beautiful cigars I've seen. The flavor is amazing. I definitely think this will be somet…
Reviewed Sep 11, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Davidoff Nicaragua
Pretty good flavor. I have to smoke more to really get into it, the draw is okay, a little bit tight but not terrible. It has a nice flavor. Definitely high quality cigar but not worth the…
Reviewed Sep 10, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Fat Bottom Betty
This is an infused cigar unfortunately, I didn't realize that when I bought it. the construction is okay but the flavor is just a just artificial tasting.
Reviewed Sep 10, 2025Read full review
Cigars
My Father Cigars Flor De Las Antillas
Construction is pretty good, not perfect. Maybe an 8 out of 10. The draw could be better, maybe a 6.5 out of 10. Flavor is a pretty good but not great it got like a 96 from Cigar Aficionado…
Reviewed Sep 7, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Perdomo Reserve 10th Anniversary Maduro
Great flavor, very smooth, with lots of complexity you can taste the fermentation. This is right up there with the davidoff I smoked last night, maybe even a bit better?
Reviewed Sep 6, 2025Read full review
Cigars
Davidoff Escurio
I can taste a lot of complex flavors right away. More than almost any other cigar right off the bat this thing has some flavor. Perfect draw all the way through, sweet flavor with smokiness…
Reviewed Sep 5, 2025Read full review
A consistent 1–10 system
What the scores mean
1–3 Skip it
4–6 Mixed to good
7–8 Recommended
9–10 Exceptional