Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next - organized in one searchable journal.

360 reviews

Cigars

Ashton review photo
Cigars

Ashton

5/10

I don't remember smoking this cigar even though I had it recently. It must not have been very memorable.

Reviewed Jul 30, 2016Read full review
norteno review photo
Cigars

Norteno

8/10

Great cigar, has the quintessential cigar flavor, the was ok, it is machined rolled which makes me appreciate hand rolled bit not bad.

Reviewed Jul 22, 2016Read full review
Rome anejo review photo
Cigars

Rome Anejo

7/10

The flavor was great, the draw wasn't great. Overall I would say it was a good experience.

Reviewed Jul 10, 2016Read full review
Boneros review photo
Cigars

Boneros

8/10

This was a very good cigar with a great draw especially. The taste was mild but good. Had a long-lasting burn.

Reviewed Jul 5, 2016Read full review
Illusions ml review photo
Cigars

Illusions Ml

7/10

This was not bad, even though it is small it lasts longer than I thought it would. Good flavor in general except the strong pepper flavor that came in sometimes.

Reviewed Jun 24, 2016Read full review
Cojonu 2012 review photo
Cigars

Cojonu 2012

7/10

This cigar had a smooth creamy flavor that was pleasant but the flavors were too mild for my taste.

Reviewed Jun 1, 2016Read full review
Oliva series g review photo
Cigars

Oliva Series G

8/10

This cigar had a great flavor, smooth. The draw was a bit too tight but still enjoyable. I like the size, didn't feel too short or too long. Lots of complexity in the flavor.

Reviewed May 28, 2016Read full review
Psyko review photo
Cigars

Psyko

8/10

Starts off sweet, gets bitter in the middle then smooth at the end. Very good cigar and a good price.

Reviewed May 28, 2016Read full review
Tabacos TB Baez Don Pepin review photo
Cigars

Tabacos TB Baez Don Pepin

8/10

This cigar was very interesting. It had a good draw it smokes slowly and had very sweet flavors at the beginning. As I got further down the cigar some real strong bitter flavors started to…

Reviewed May 15, 2016Read full review
Gurkha cellah reserv review photo
Cigars

Gurkha Cellah Reserv

7/10

Very good flavor, lots of different complex tastes. Changes as the cigar goes by. The major complaint is the draw is too fast . Even though it's a short cigar it last a long time.

Reviewed May 12, 2016Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional