Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next - organized in one searchable journal.

360 reviews

Cigars

cao Colombia review photo
Cigars

Cao Colombia

8/10

The cigar has a good draw and a very good smoke output. There is a woodiness to the taste that I don't often taste in cigars.

Reviewed Apr 7, 2017Read full review
my father review photo
Cigars

My Father

8/10

Great construction on this cigar. The smoke output is also very good. Good flavor, a bit of spice to it very pleasant though not the peppery kind. The taste stays on the tongue long after t…

Reviewed Apr 3, 2017Read full review
l'atelier  review photo
Cigars

L'atelier

8/10

The construction on this cigar is fantastic. The draw is smooth and a flavors full body too. The rapper has a nice sheen on it. Very nice smoke output as well.

Reviewed Mar 31, 2017Read full review
La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull review photo
Cigars

La Flor Dominicana Andalusian Bull

7/10

This was rated 2016 number one cigar in Cigar Aficionado. I definitely would not rated the best cigar I have had this year, not really even close. This is not to say that it was a bad cigar…

Reviewed Mar 30, 2017Read full review
perdomo 20th anniversary review photo
Cigars

Perdomo 20th Anniversary

7/10

It seems like this cigar was not stored with proper humidity. I will try to keep this in mind when I give my rating. Nice smooth smoke. Kind of a creaminess to it. The Taste is light to med…

Reviewed Mar 14, 2017Read full review
the edge a-10 review photo
Cigars

The Edge A-10

4/10

the draw is hard and not good. The initial flavor is on the bigger side. Although the presentation is very nice I like the color difference between the two wrappers.

Reviewed Mar 10, 2017Read full review
la castia criolla review photo
Cigars

La Castia Criolla

4/10

The construction is fantastic and I feel like the wrapper is a very high quality. The Taste has a lot of cardboard to it. Not very pleasant. As good as the construction is in the draw The T…

Reviewed Mar 3, 2017Read full review
natural drew estate review photo
Cigars

Natural Drew Estate

7/10

I didn't realize this was a flavored cigar but it taste very good and it has a good draw and it tastes like the tobacco is also very good quality.

Reviewed Mar 1, 2017Read full review
te-amo world selection series review photo
Cigars

Te-amo World Selection Series

7/10

The wrapper is coming off a little bit but I suspect that is because of the quality of a humidor it was stored in and not the quality of the cigar itself. It has a very interesting tastes.…

Reviewed Feb 16, 2017Read full review
punch signature  review photo
Cigars

Punch Signature

7/10

I have not had a lot of punches but this is constructed very well and very firm on the outside the gauges huge and it's a little bit too big for maximum comfort in my mouth. The flavor does…

Reviewed Feb 15, 2017Read full review
alec Bradley prensado review photo
Cigars

Alec Bradley Prensado

7/10

The cigar has a nice smell before it is lit. It is machine rolled. The draw is a little bit on the tight side but still good. A little bit of spiciness to the flavor.

Reviewed Feb 12, 2017Read full review
Carrillo oscuro  review photo
Cigars

Carrillo Oscuro

6/10

Kind of a light-bodied cigar. Good construction, good draw. this one was rated very highly by Cigar Aficionado. It's not bad but I'm not really seeing why they gave it such a high score.

Reviewed Jan 17, 2017Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional