Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next - organized in one searchable journal.

360 reviews

Cigars

archetype strange passage review photo
Cigars

Archetype Strange Passage

7/10

This is the best flavor of a cigar that I've had in a long time. The construction is very good as well as the smoke out put. A lot of spiciness in the taste which I don't think I normally l…

Reviewed Jun 7, 2017Read full review
h. upmann the banker 1844 review photo
Cigars

H. Upmann The Banker 1844

7/10

Decent draw of the it is a little tight. The smoke out put is decent too, The Taste is on the better side. Construction is okay it seems a little bit soft I prefer a real hard rigid outside.

Reviewed Jun 3, 2017Read full review
cao gold maduro review photo
Cigars

Cao Gold Maduro

5/10

The draw is a bit on the Poor Side. Smoke output is medium too poor. The texture of the outside feels good smooth, seems like it's been aged. A slight sheen from oils. It has a bit of a uni…

Reviewed May 28, 2017Read full review
revolution review photo
Cigars

Revolution

8/10

Not hand-rolled but the construction is fantastic. The smoke output is also very good. The Taste is robust but definitely the weakest link in this cigar. I would definitely buy the cigar ag…

Reviewed May 26, 2017Read full review
v project 805 cubra Madurai andullo review photo
Cigars

V Project 805 Cubra Madurai Andullo

8/10

The cigar seems like a very good bargain. It has good Construction good output of smoke and a very complex flavor a bit of bitterness but a very deep and Rich flavor behind the bitterness.…

Reviewed May 24, 2017Read full review
aging room quattro review photo
Cigars

Aging Room Quattro

8/10

The draw is very good, almost perfect but not quite the smoke output I would like. Very smooth subtle flavors comma creaminess to the smoke. Overall very enjoyable I highly recommend this.

Reviewed May 20, 2017Read full review
macanudo review photo
Cigars

Macanudo

6/10

Construction is decent, smoke output is fantastic. Smoke has a hint of cardboard which is not pleasant but it's also kind of creamy and there's some other complexity to it. Some spice to it…

Reviewed May 12, 2017Read full review
onyx reserve  review photo
Cigars

Onyx Reserve

6/10

A terrible draw. If it wasn't for that I think I would have enjoyed this cigar much more. A nice dark Rich taste with a slight tinge of bitterness but not much. Along with the poor job ther…

Reviewed May 1, 2017Read full review
the mason Dixon project MMXV review photo
Cigars

The Mason Dixon Project MMXV

6/10

Good Construction, decent smoke output and good thickness. The flavor was complex although not as good as I would have hoped. I could see this flavor being very good for someone else howeve…

Reviewed May 1, 2017Read full review
cao maduro review photo
Cigars

Cao Maduro

6/10

The draw is not very good. The flavor is not bad very typical cigar flavor. Pretty smooth.

Reviewed Apr 28, 2017Read full review
Carlos torano exodus 1959 review photo
Cigars

Carlos Torano Exodus 1959

8/10

Decent Construction, good flavors a bit on the bigger side a decent amount of complexity to them. The shape of the cigar is very nice and the draw is good in the Smoke output is good as wel…

Reviewed Apr 17, 2017Read full review
macanudo maduro review photo
Cigars

Macanudo Maduro

8/10

Has a bit of an unusual Aroma to it that I have not had before. The Taste is on the better side but with some complexity to it. I enjoy it. Good construction and a very good draw.

Reviewed Apr 14, 2017Read full review
fonseca nicaragua review photo
Cigars

Fonseca Nicaragua

6/10

The draw is not too great, construction is decent but not above-average. The flavor was pretty decent. For the price around $6 it was not a bad deal but you don't get the quality from the t…

Reviewed Apr 14, 2017Read full review
cao flathead 554 review photo
Cigars

Cao Flathead 554

7/10

Not a bad cigar I am liking all the cao flatheads. This one is probably the least good however but still enjoyable.

Reviewed Apr 9, 2017Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional