Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next - organized in one searchable journal.

360 reviews

Cigars

Oliva Serie O  review photo
Cigars

Oliva Serie O

7/10

The draw on the cigar is pretty good, I can taste some nice fermentation on the tobacco. Getting to the second half of this cigar, same flavors but a little bit more bold now.

Reviewed Aug 6, 2025Read full review
plasencia reserva original  review photo
Cigars

Plasencia Reserva Original

8/10

Very good flavor and very good draw This is, all in all, a pretty great stick for the price. This is kind of what I think of when I think of Plasencia: sophisticated taste, particularly goo…

Reviewed Aug 4, 2025Read full review
Monte Cristo Platinum series review photo
Cigars

Monte Cristo Platinum Series

6/10

I do detect a little bit of spice to this, not super strong flavors but the flavors that are there are pleasant. The construction is decent though not perfect there's a little softness to i…

Reviewed Aug 3, 2025Read full review
Rocky Patel 10th anniversary review photo
Cigars

Rocky Patel 10th Anniversary

7/10

Nice and smooth. It has a good flavor to it I've had these before, and the construction is almost always great. The flavor is not top-tier but it's definitely better than average and pretty…

Reviewed Jul 30, 2025Read full review
Megilla rare cut Habano review photo
Cigars

Megilla Rare Cut Habano

5/10

This is a pretty good cigar with a very nice draw, a little bit of bitterness on the tail end and a little bit of sweetness and creaminess throughout the whole thing at the beginning especi…

Reviewed Jul 29, 2025Read full review
the Oscar valladares review photo
Cigars

The Oscar Valladares

7/10

Reconstruction like most of the Oscars cigars have. It has an interesting flavor that the other Oscars don't seem to have. I'm having trouble to come up with words to describe it. Somewhat…

Reviewed Oct 21, 2018Read full review
island jim review photo
Cigars

Island Jim

6/10

Has a triple cap with different types of leaves but I couldn't get a good draw without taking them all off. Aside from that the draw is good as is the construction although it doesn't look…

Reviewed Aug 25, 2018Read full review
h. upmana 1844 nicaragua review photo
Cigars

H. Upmana 1844 Nicaragua

7/10

The draw on the cigar is pretty bad. It takes 3 or 4 Puffs before you can get a decent amount of smoke on the inhale. When you finally get some smoke The Taste is pretty decent. It's a litt…

Reviewed Aug 10, 2018Read full review
gurkha cellar reserve aged 12 years review photo
Cigars

Gurkha Cellar Reserve Aged 12 Years

8/10

I like the 15-year Reserve so much I wanted to go back and try the 12. This one has a bit more spice than the 15 year, and it lingers on the tongue a little bit longer and sharper. It reall…

Reviewed Jun 9, 2018Read full review
gurkha cellar reserve aged 15 years review photo
Cigars

Gurkha Cellar Reserve Aged 15 Years

7/10

After taking a draw my mouth explodes with flavors. There's a good amount of spice to the flavor but subtle notes of cinnamon and even vanilla which are strange things to use to describe a…

Reviewed Jun 2, 2018Read full review
ghurka ghost review photo
Cigars

Ghurka Ghost

5/10

This cigar starts off with a ton of spice. It has a medium draw and a good amount of smoke output. Has a good amount of bitter flavor coming in with a spice. As I get a little further into…

Reviewed May 25, 2018Read full review
illusione fume d'amour review photo
Cigars

Illusione Fume D'amour

8/10

This has a sweet taste to it. Great Smoke output and a good draw. There's a little bit of spice but not too much. Very nice construction on the cigar with a matte finish.

Reviewed May 23, 2018Read full review
illusione fume d'amour review photo
Cigars

Illusione Fume D'amour

8/10

This has a sweet taste to it. Great Smoke output and a good draw. There's a little bit of spice but not too much. Very nice construction on the cigar with a matte finish.

Reviewed May 23, 2018Read full review
la Gloria Cubans serie r review photo
Cigars

La Gloria Cubans Serie R

6/10

The draw is a little bit tight but not very unpleasant. It started off very spicy but it's getting more mellow as I get further down the cigar. The burn is not very even, although it's seem…

Reviewed May 8, 2018Read full review
illusions epernay review photo
Cigars

Illusions Epernay

7/10

Lots of spice in the flavor but not black pepper. Very good smoke output and very easy draw. The construction on this is fantastic.

Reviewed May 5, 2018Read full review
cao Amazon basin review photo
Cigars

Cao Amazon Basin

8/10

This is a brand that I am normally quite fond of. They usually have consistent Construction and good draws. This one is no exception. It's taking me awhile to Define The Taste I'm getting f…

Reviewed Feb 24, 2018Read full review
padron 1926 40 years review photo
Cigars

Padron 1926 40 Years

8/10

This is a very fine cigar. Very smooth smoke a great draw pretty close to mild to medium. The smoke is velvety the same way the wrapper looks.

Reviewed Dec 15, 2017Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional