Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.

Reviews from the things I actually try

Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next - organized in one searchable journal.

360 reviews

Cigars

Leaf by Oscar Broadleaf cigar review photo
Cigars

Leaf By Oscar Broadleaf Cigar

7/10

So far, so good. Getting a decent draw. Not a huge amount of flavor coming off it right now, but it's just the beginning, so we'll see how it develops from here. I'm a little bit into the c…

Reviewed Nov 18, 2026Read full review
El Mago Defender Cigar Cameroon review photo
Cigars

El Mago Defender Cigar Cameroon

8/10

The first thing I noticed is how good the draw is. The construction of the cigar seems to be very good. Getting some notes of hay and cocoa. Off to a really good start. I'm interested to se…

Reviewed Nov 6, 2026Read full review
Tatuaje Monster review photo
Cigars

Tatuaje Monster

7/10

Great draw, huge stick. Lots of bitter notes at the beginning. 23 minutes in, the flavors have developed. They're a bit sweeter now and really nice. This is a really delicious cigar so far.…

Reviewed Oct 30, 2026Read full review
Arturo fuente rare pink review photo
Cigars

Arturo Fuente Rare Pink

8/10

Starting off with a good draw, nice flavors to begin with. Sweet and smooth. Very good flavor profile. 22 minutes in starting to get some really interesting unusual flavors. Getting that de…

Reviewed Oct 25, 2026Read full review
Oscar Valladares Altar Q review photo
Cigars

Oscar Valladares Altar Q

5/10

Really good draw, not a lot of flavor at the beginning, we will see how it develops. The wrapper peeled off around the mouth area right away, the flavor never really matured. It just tastes…

Reviewed Oct 9, 2026Read full review
Charter Oak Connecticut Maduro review photo
Cigars

Charter Oak Connecticut Maduro

7/10

A really good draw is the first thing. I noticed. Some real deep earthy flavors coming in. Some nutty flavors some Cocoa flavor I think. Very interesting flavor profile very early on. I'll…

Reviewed Oct 7, 2026Read full review
Apostate The Feathered Serpent review photo
Cigars

Apostate The Feathered Serpent

5/10

Overall there were some interesting flavors, but the draw was not very good, which really diminished the enjoyment of the cigar. Someone else I was with was smoking the same cigar and had t…

Reviewed Oct 4, 2026Read full review
Joya de Nicaragua Clásico Original review photo
Cigars

Joya De Nicaragua Clásico Original

9/10

My first impression is the draw is amazing. Just exactly what you want, the initial flavor profile is kind of bread-tasting starting off. Kind of on the mild side. I guess you would say, bu…

Reviewed Oct 1, 2026Read full review
God of Fire Cigar Carlito 2020 review photo
Cigars

God Of Fire Cigar Carlito 2020

7/10

It's kind of a good draw. Some subtle flavors that are starting out at the beginning, kind of an earthy vibe, a little mellow at this point. About 50 minutes in. I haven't gotten very far,…

Reviewed Sep 27, 2026Read full review
Liga Privada  H99 review photo
Cigars

Liga Privada H99

8/10

Lancero with a great draw. Getting nuttiness and earth, wood, jungle. 20 minutes in the flavor gets stronger and stronger. It does have a tendency to start to grow out so you got to keep pu…

Reviewed Sep 21, 2026Read full review
AJ Fernandez Enclave Broadleaf review photo
Cigars

AJ Fernandez Enclave Broadleaf

8/10

The first thing to note is that the draw is absolutely incredible. This is essentially a perfect draw. This has a little bit of rubber to it, not in a bad way if you can imagine that though…

Reviewed Sep 19, 2026Read full review
Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro review photo
Cigars

Drew Estate Undercrown Maduro

7/10

Very good draw and good smoke production, has a very dry taste to it. Getting some grassy notes right from the beginning. Not much else at this point. Maybe a little bit of earth. I am 38 m…

Reviewed Sep 11, 2026Read full review
Highclere Castle Victorian review photo
Cigars

Highclere Castle Victorian

10/10

The cigar has a red label, good looking wrapper. Nice arombo before I even start smoking it. Kind of a sweet smell on the tobacco before I've lit it. Let's see how it turns out. My perspect…

Reviewed Sep 7, 2026Read full review
Warped La Colmena Cocoladrillo review photo
Cigars

Warped La Colmena Cocoladrillo

7/10

Very nice cigar. Lots of campfire flavors, wood, a bit of caramel and chocolate. If it had a better draw it would be a real gem but even without the perfect draw on the flavors are really v…

Reviewed Sep 5, 2026Read full review
Tatuaje miami review photo
Cigars

Tatuaje Miami

9/10

Amazing construction, amazing draw. Great flavors immediately hitting you from the very first puff. You don't have to wait for anything to develop with this thing. Getting notes of wood, pl…

Reviewed Sep 4, 2026Read full review
Illusione Singulare review photo
Cigars

Illusione Singulare

6/10

The draw's a little bit tight. Not terrible though. I can still smoke it. Fortunately the smoke output is still really good. Starting off with a bunch of Woody notes. A hint of cardboard. L…

Reviewed Sep 2, 2026Read full review

A consistent 1–10 system

What the scores mean

1–3 Skip it

4–6 Mixed to good

7–8 Recommended

9–10 Exceptional