Cigars
Nat Sherman NYC 1930
There is some spiciness to this. The draw is a slight bit tight but not unusual.
Reviewed Jul 26, 2017Read full review
Firsthand reviews. No sponsored rankings.
Reviews from the things I actually try
Cigars, beer, spirits, food, fragrance, and whatever comes next—organized in one searchable journal.
335 reviews
Cigars
Cigars
A. J. Fernandez New World
The draw on this was not very good for most of the smoke. The construction was a little bit Loose as well. Overall I felt it was not a quality smoke.
Reviewed Jul 20, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Diamond Crown Julius Caesar
The flavor is Bittersweet, literally. The construction is okay, the draw is very good. I would not say that this is the best tasting cigar that I have had but it is the most unique tasting.…
Reviewed Jul 15, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Rocky Patel Special Reserve Sun-grown Maduro
I'm normally not a big Rocky Patel fan this one however is not terrible. I wouldn't say it's spectacular but most of the time I really dislike Rocky Patels. The construction is very good. T…
Reviewed Jul 8, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Alec Bradley Filthy Hooligan Black Market
This has a perfect draw very good Construction and I really like the flavors immediately from the start. More in the light side of flavor but not too light.
Reviewed Jul 1, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Casa Magna Jalapa Claro
Very nice construction and very nice draw. Medium-bodied flavor so nice complexity in the smoke with some sweet notes as the most noticeable.
Reviewed Jun 27, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Perdomo Reserve Champagne Noir
All around good quality, I really enjoyed the taste and the smell of this cigar. He reminds me of when I was young and I used to smell a good smelling cigar being smoked by somebody else.
Reviewed Jun 25, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Antano Dark Corojo
Very good Construction. The draw is decent very rich flavors are coming through.
Reviewed Jun 24, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Headley Grange Republica Dominica
the drama is not great but has a very nice deep rich flavor. I have been getting into the larger gauges and this one is a bit smaller but not bad.
Reviewed Jun 20, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Cao Cameroon 1968
Good construction, hard wrapper. Very good smoke output in the draw is very easy. Taste starts off sweet and then becomes a bit bitter by the Finish. Lots of complex flavors happening they'…
Reviewed Jun 13, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Perdomo Habano Connecticut
Lot of spice and pepper right in the front. The construction is mediocre in the draw is a little bit sub-par but not terrible. All in all not really my thing although I could see how this c…
Reviewed Jun 11, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Archetype Strange Passage
This is the best flavor of a cigar that I've had in a long time. The construction is very good as well as the smoke out put. A lot of spiciness in the taste which I don't think I normally l…
Reviewed Jun 7, 2017Read full review
Cigars
H. Upmann The Banker 1844
Decent draw of the it is a little tight. The smoke out put is decent too, The Taste is on the better side. Construction is okay it seems a little bit soft I prefer a real hard rigid outside.
Reviewed Jun 3, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Gurkha
Very good construction, very good smoke output good flavor everything about this cigar is very enjoyable.
Reviewed May 31, 2017Read full review
Cigars
San Lotano Habano By A.j. Fernandez
Great construction and a fantastic draw. Some spiciness to the flavor kind of a medium body.
Reviewed May 30, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Cao Gold Maduro
The draw is a bit on the Poor Side. Smoke output is medium too poor. The texture of the outside feels good smooth, seems like it's been aged. A slight sheen from oils. It has a bit of a uni…
Reviewed May 28, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Revolution
Not hand-rolled but the construction is fantastic. The smoke output is also very good. The Taste is robust but definitely the weakest link in this cigar. I would definitely buy the cigar ag…
Reviewed May 26, 2017Read full review
Cigars
V Project 805 Cubra Madurai Andullo
The cigar seems like a very good bargain. It has good Construction good output of smoke and a very complex flavor a bit of bitterness but a very deep and Rich flavor behind the bitterness.…
Reviewed May 24, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Alec Bradley Nica Puro 1685
Decent Construction, medium draw. The flavor is not really good or bad. Overall and enjoyable smoke but nothing to write home about.
Reviewed May 22, 2017Read full review
Cigars
Aging Room Quattro
The draw is very good, almost perfect but not quite the smoke output I would like. Very smooth subtle flavors comma creaminess to the smoke. Overall very enjoyable I highly recommend this.
Reviewed May 20, 2017Read full review
A consistent 1–10 system
What the scores mean
1–3 Skip it
4–6 Mixed to good
7–8 Recommended
9–10 Exceptional