Cigar Rating Scale

This 1–10 scale reflects not just quality, but the full smoking experience — construction, draw, flavor, and overall enjoyment. It’s subjective, but consistent enough to help you gauge where a cigar stands in real-world terms.

1. Unsmokable — something went very wrong. Plugged draw, mold, unraveling wrapper, or so acrid you can’t finish it.
2. Smokable, technically — but harsh, bitter, or otherwise so unpleasant it isn’t worth the time or the match.
3. Manageable but disappointing — the kind of cigar you finish out of curiosity or politeness, not pleasure.
4. Poorly made or poorly tasting — bad burn, uneven construction, or a flavor profile that just misses the mark completely.
5. Neutral — neither good nor bad. You could smoke it again, but you wouldn’t remember it tomorrow.
6. Decent — enjoyable enough that you’d have another if offered, but not one you’d go looking for.
7. Solid and satisfying — a cigar you’d gladly buy again; dependable, flavorful, and enjoyable from start to finish.
8. Excellent — distinct character, balanced flavors, and a memorable experience worth keeping a few in the humidor.
9. Exceptional — rare, standout cigar that delivers a remarkable smoking experience; something you talk about afterward.
10. Legendary — one of the finest cigars you’ve ever had. Perfect construction, sublime flavor, unforgettable from first draw to last ash.